When compiling a list of the best beach towns, the omission of Sanibel Island would be truly incomplete. We wholeheartedly agree with Southern Living for recognizing the undeniable allure of this exceptional destination, ranking it proudly at No. 6 in their esteemed “The 50 Best Beach Towns in the South 2025” list. This prestigious recognition also positions Sanibel as the top-rated Florida beach town on their list, a testament to its enduring appeal.
Southern Living acknowledged the ongoing recovery of Sanibel Island following the impact of Hurricane Ian in September 2022, as well as Hurricanes Milton and Helene in 2024.
Despite these challenges, Southern Living beautifully captured the spirit of Sanibel, stating:
A sunny slice of paradise that’s as resilient as they come, Sanibel was struck by three hurricanes (Ian, Helene, and Milton) in the span of just over two years, but it continues to persevere. With no stoplights or high-rises, the island is an old-school beach town at its best. Once you’ve come here, it won’t be long before you’ve adopted the Sanibel stoop, the well-known posture of serious shell seekers.
Indeed, as many who have visited will attest, Sanibel Island possesses a captivating charm that often steals hearts unexpectedly. The scenic drive over the causeway unveils a breathtaking panorama: 17,000 acres of lush natural beauty bordered by the sparkling Gulf of Mexico on one side and the tranquil San Carlos Bay on the other.
Stepping onto Sanibel, you’ll immediately sense a departure from the hustle and bustle of nearby cities like Tampa and Fort Myers. The absence of stoplights, high-rises, and sprawling chain stores contributes to an atmosphere of serene tranquility. This unique character fosters a strong sense of community, local pride, and an appreciation for the island’s remarkable natural treasures.
Southern Living further highlights the “9 Best things to do in Sanibel Island,” which includes the beloved pastime of searching for shells, along with opportunities for walking and biking along scenic wildlife trails, and a delightful selection of places to eat and stay.
It’s wonderful to see other gems on the Gulf Coast recognized as well, with Naples ranking at No. 22 and Captiva Island, Sanibel’s close neighbor, securing the No. 25 spot, Siesta Key comes in at 15, and authentic Anna Maria Island finishes at 11.
The No. 1 best beach town in the South, according to Southern Living, is St. Simons Island, Georgia, praised for its alluring atmosphere, delicious shrimp, stunning sunsets, and a wealth of activities ranging from wildlife viewing and sailing to biking and exploring historical landmarks.
However, for those seeking an authentic beach town experience renowned for its natural beauty and world-class shelling, Sanibel Island remains an unparalleled destination. We invite you to discover the magic of Sanibel firsthand by staying at one of our many vacation rentals. From condos to pool homes, beachfront stays, and pet-friendly getaways we have every option available.
To read Southern Livings full list of the 50 Beast Beach Towns In The South, click here.
Fall colors paint the Sanibel sky
Seashells, Sunsets, Sea Life, & Serenades
September is a special time on Sanibel Island. It’s perfect for couples, romance, and quiet times with friends.
The sky becomes a more vibrant shade of blue, the Sanibel summer crowd disappears and the warm breezes and the spectacular sunset are all the excuse you’ll need for a romantic evening beach stroll. If you’re lucky, you may come across turtle hatchlings as they emerge from their nests to begin a life at sea. Fall colors on the island are displayed in the sunsets. Toward the end of the month, Grammy award winning Country Music stars arrive in the area to serenade residents and guests. Many of the events are free and all are open to the public. Read on for more information.
Romantic Sanibel Island Beach Walks
It’s the perfect time to stroll the beach and discover the seashells that make Sanibel Island a world-famous destination. Each wave brings with it new and different treasures. Shelling is best at low tide, but who needs a reason to walk the beach? A walk by the shore is a wonderful way to spend some time and reconnect with your special someone or group of friends.
Strolling the beach, a perfect way to spend the day.
Sanibel Island is often thought of as a great family destination or seasonal rental location. Recently we are becoming a sought-out destination for couples looking for a romantic place to get engaged, tie the knot or renew their vows. Many people recall coming to Sanibel as a child and the happy memories call them back as an adult to recapture those memories and begin making their own.
Sanibel Island is a romantic place to pop-the-question or rekindle your romance.
On The Water
When the urge to get on the water hits, choose from kayaks, stand up paddleboards or motorized watercraft. We have protected waters to explore or you can head out to the Gulf. The bay side of the island will provide you with the most wildlife sightings. You’ll see manatees, all types of water birds, dolphins, and a large variety of fish. It’s a great way to explore Sanibel Island and Captiva Island. Get a different perspective of the islands from the water.
Head out for a day of exploring on the water
Sunsets
A favorite evening pastime is watching the sunset. You can do this from your screened-in lanai, if you are staying in one of our Sanibel Island beachfront rentals, or bring chairs to the beach and watch the sun sink into the Gulf. Each sunset is unique and is always an awe-inspiring way to end the day. Bring your favorite beverage to the beach and toast this evening event.
Create your own evening Sanibel sunset celebration.
Turtle Hatchlings
In the spring, sea turtles arrive on Sanibel’s beaches to dig their nests and lay their eggs. In September the hatchlings emerge from the nests and scurry to the sea to begin their lives. The turtles are the reason beachfront guests are asked to close their drapes, remove debris and fill in holes on the beach, and keep exterior lights shaded away from the beach at night. When the baby turtles hatch, they use the light of the moon and stars reflecting off the water as their guide back to the water. Lights from human activity confuse them. They travel in the wrong direction and the outcome can be fatal to them. If you are lucky, you may witness a nest hatch. Please watch from a distance. It’s an experience you won’t forget.
Turtle hatchlings on their way to the sea
Island Hopper Songwriter Festival
The weekend of September 22nd the Fourth Annual Island Hopper Songwriters Festival comes to Captiva Island. It moves to downtown Fort Myers during the week and finishes on Fort Myers Beach Sunday, October 1. Give Island Vacations a call. We have a limited number of properties that can accommodate the unusual stay schedule. Call early to before they are booked. These reservations must be made by phone – 1-800=451-7277. This gathering of Grammy Award Award-winning country music songwriters is a must see for country fans. Most shows are free. You just walk from venue to venue listening to these talented singer/songwriters and enjoy the stories they share that lead up to the song\’s creation! It’s becoming known as one of the best events in Southwest Florida.
Brian Sutherland performs at last year’s Island Hopper. Casual dress is a must!
Sanibel Island in September is a perfect destination for couples looking for a romantic getaway, a quiet, relaxing stay or time with friends. Wrap up your September stay with a weekend of award winning musicians. Visit us in September for a different type of Island Vacation experience.